First, Crack Them Open (Like Americans Do!) (Published 2008) (2024)

Food|First, Crack Them Open (Like Americans Do!)

https://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/27/dining/27fortune.html

Supported by

SKIP ADVERTIsem*nT

THE instructions on the red wrapper are very explicit: (1) Open the packaging. (2) Use both hands to break open the fortune cookie. (3) Retrieve and read the fortune. (4) Eat the cookie.

In China, such details are necessary, it seems.

“Chinese people don’t know what to do with a fortune cookie,” said Nana Shi, who started an online business last October that is likely the only company currently selling fortune cookies in China. “They don’t know that you have to open it.”

Although most Americans think of fortune cookies as Chinese, the crispy curved wafers that are given away free by the billions in the United States every year are all but unknown in China.

In recent years, research by a Japanese scholar named Yasuko Nakamachi has shown that fortune cookies almost certainly originated in Japan, and were brought to the United States by immigrant bakers.

Image

Ms. Shi, 40, who lives in Beijing, first became intrigued by the cookies at a Chinese restaurant during a visit to California in 2001. “I thought, Why don’t we have these in China?” she said.

In 2006, she started putting together a business. She bought a fortune cookie machine from a businessman in China who had imported it but never used it. Her company, Beijing Fortune Cookies, has 16 employees and is growing.

Ms. Shi’s Web site, www.fortunecookieslucky.com, markets the cookies mostly as high-end gifts. For Christmas and Halloween (neither of which is a traditional holiday in China), she offers bulk packages of themed fortune cookie favors for $20. Other sets are packaged as wedding favors, graduation presents, tokens of appreciation and birthday gifts. The cookies are occasionally covered with chocolate or sprinkles.

Restaurant owners in China have been skeptical of giving the cookies away. “They think, ‘If I give this for free to my customers, that raises my cost,’” Ms. Shi said.

The cookies are similar in size, shape and color to those in the United States, but her recipe is slightly different. For example, no butter is used because some Chinese avoid animal products.

Image

Ms. Shi is not the first to try selling fortune cookies in China. In 1992, the Brooklyn-based company Wonton Food — now the largest fortune cookie manufacturer in the world — tried to open a partnership with the Guangzhou Municipal Foodstuffs Machinery Corporation. The project was abandoned within five years, in part because the cookies were “too American,” according to a Wonton Food executive.

But now Mrs. Shi is betting that times have changed, though the concept of the fortune cookie is still perplexing to potential consumers. The presence of the paper fortunes — either in their mouth or in the cookie — generally takes Chinese people by surprise.

“They always think it’s contamination of some sort,” Ms. Shi said.

The hollow bent shape of the fortune cookie seems to be a difficult concept to grasp. “They will ask: ‘How do you get a piece of paper inside a cookie? It doesn’t make sense,’” she said.

The fortunes, which are printed in Chinese on one side and English on the other, come from writers Ms. Shi solicits through online help wanted ads. They include “Good interpersonal relationships are the greatest treasure. Use them properly”; and “Knowledge of language is the gateway to wisdom.”

She has amassed quite a repertory. “I have 8,000 fortunes in my collection,” she said. “These are my assets. Someone else could buy a machine and make cookies, but they can’t get to the same number of fortunes that I have.”

Asked if any of the fortunes had to do with Confucius, she looked surprised and said, “No.”

Advertisem*nt

SKIP ADVERTIsem*nT

First, Crack Them Open (Like Americans Do!) (Published 2008) (2024)

FAQs

Are you supposed to read the fortune or eat the cookie first? ›

THE instructions on the red wrapper are very explicit: (1) Open the packaging. (2) Use both hands to break open the fortune cookie. (3) Retrieve and read the fortune. (4) Eat the cookie.

Do you eat fortune cookie paper? ›

There are several drawbacks associated with conventional fortune cookies. First, because the fortune is written on a piece of paper, the consumer needs to crack open the cookie and remove the paper before eating the cookie.

Where did the fortune cookie originate? ›

The latest history of the fortune cookie is that it originated in Japan. A wood block image from 1878 shows what seems to be a Japanese street vendor grilling, fortune cookies. They can still be found in certain districts of Kyoto Japan, but are larger and darker than the fortune cookie we are familiar with.

What does it mean when you open a fortune cookie and there's no fortune in it? ›

You are in control of your own future and are able to take the reins and make what you want to happen, happen. You have everything you need to move forward and bring in good energy. Although it may be a little less fun, no fortune is nothing to worry about. It doesn't mean that you have no future or luck.

What do the numbers at the bottom of a fortune cookie mean? ›

The numbers on the fortune cookie's are lucky numbers. The numbers are "lucky" , so everytime you see that number, you know that something lucky is going to happen… i think.

Are fortune cookies unhealthy? ›

A cookie may have sugar varying from 0–3 g, between 2–8 mg of sodium, and may have significant (compared to their size) amounts of iron or protein. The small size means they have little overall nutritional value.

Do fortune cookies taste good? ›

The typical fortune cookies, in all honesty, taste like cardboard. Who actually enjoys the cookies? On the other hand, homemade fortune cookies are absolutely delicious! Sweet, crunchy wafer-like cookies with a hint of vanilla, and paired with a homemade fortune?!

Are fortune cookies baked with the paper? ›

Answer. The cookies are baked as flat circles. After they are removed from the oven, slips of paper are folded inside while the cookies are still warm and flexible. As the fortune cookies cool, they harden into shape.

Do Asians eat fortune cookies? ›

While Chinese restaurants all over the world serve fortune cookies, the ones in China don't. In fact, the concept is so foreign, says TIME, that when Wonton Food Inc., one of the biggest purveyors of fortune cookies, tried to do business in China in the 1990s, diners kept eating the fortunes by mistake.

Can my dog have fortune cookies? ›

Technically, yes, dogs can eat fortune cookies. Fortune cookies are basic foods with few ingredients, and it is safe to give them to your dog in most circ*mstances. However, fortune cookies are not necessarily good for dogs. Dogs do not need to eat processed foods and sugars.

How many fortune cookies does wonton food in Brooklyn, New York make each day? ›

During this transition, Wonton Food gave TIME a look behind the scenes at its Queens, N.Y. factory, which churns out 4.5 million fortune cookies a day, to see fortune-cookie history in the making.

Do supermarkets sell fortune cookies? ›

The Original Fortune Cookies - ASDA Groceries.

What race are fortune cookies? ›

Lee says the fortune cookie likely arrived in the United States along with Japanese immigrants who came to Hawaii and California between the 1880s and early 1900s, after the Chinese Exclusion Act's expulsion of Chinese workers left a demand for cheap labor. Japanese bakers set up shop in places such as Los Angeles and ...

Why don't fortune cookies have fortunes anymore? ›

Simply put, they no longer tell fortunes because the family-run companies that dominate this business cannot keep up with demand. Yet that doesn't spoil the fun of fortune cookies. Some companies create "adult" messages, and a few allow patrons to create their own fortunes.

What is the lucky number fortune cookie? ›

This will give you a better chance at winning the lottery

The six numbers in FORTUNE COOKIES associated with the most winners are: 4, 14, 15, 22, 26 and 28.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Van Hayes

Last Updated:

Views: 5651

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Van Hayes

Birthday: 1994-06-07

Address: 2004 Kling Rapid, New Destiny, MT 64658-2367

Phone: +512425013758

Job: National Farming Director

Hobby: Reading, Polo, Genealogy, amateur radio, Scouting, Stand-up comedy, Cryptography

Introduction: My name is Van Hayes, I am a thankful, friendly, smiling, calm, powerful, fine, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.